The purpose of
writing this letter to President Obama is not to play a role of the Kurdish
Ambassador. I have written to him before. However, this time is about the US policy
towards the Kurdistan Democratic party (KDP) and Patriotic Union of Kurdistan
(PUK). The US government still has blacklisted the KDP and PUK as terrorist
organizations. On the one hand, the US has its consulate in Kurdistan, which
administered by these two Kurdish parties, and greets the leaders of these
parties at the White House; on the other hand, it has enlisted them as
terrorist organizations. This US policy
towards these Kurdish political parties is unjust, and it certainly is an
insult to the national integrity of the people of Kurdistan.
Barack Obama, President
United States of America
The White House
1600 Pennsylvania Avenue NW
Washington, DC 20500
June 23, 2013
Honorable President Obama:
Mr. President, the people of
Kurdistan are a part of the world in which you have been trying to alleviate human
suffering; however, they have suffered so much at the hand of the dictatorial
regimes that were supported by the all-too-powerful superpowers from post WWI
on.
During the past nine decades, the
Kurds have been living a sort of “enslavement” in Iran, Iraq, Syria and Turkey.
From a nation that had created the second largest empire, the Median Empire, in
ancient history—a nation that had all the nationhood characteristics, land,
culture, distinct language, and history—have become minorities in these
countries and have been living in the shadow of Arabs, Persians and Turks.
Every time the people of Kurdistan in any part of Kurdistan, challenged these
nation states to achieve their God-given rights, the Western powers were there
to assist these central governments to prevent the people of Kurdistan from achieving
their national rights. Since it became a world’s superpower after the WWII,
America, in particular, has been supporting Turkey and Iran (during the Shah’s
regime) to suppress the Kurdish identity and rights.
Further, it seems that even after
the first decade of the twenty first century, America does not have a clear
agenda for the people of Kurdistan. For example, during the US invasion of Iraq
in 2003 to topple Saddam Hussein’s despotic regime, the Kurdish forces of
Kurdistan Democratic Party (KDP) headed by Masoud Barzanî, and Patriotic Union
of Kurdistan (PUK) led by Jalal Talabani, became American foot soldiers and
facilitated the removal of Saddam Hussein from power. Furthermore, following Saddam
Hussein’s removal, Masoud Barzanî was first amongst the leaders in Iraq to call
for national reconciliation in Iraq. When Jalal Talabani became the first
Kurdish president of Iraq, and Masoud Barzanî became president of Kurdistan, both
Kurdish presidents, Barzanî in Hewlêr (Erbil) and Talabani in Baghdad did their
due diligence to assist the US to succeed in Iraq. The two Kurdish leaders were
the intervening and reconciliatory voices between the opposing Arab factions in
Iraq. While in Baghdad, prior to his illness, Jalal Talabani was able to
maintain stability amongst and in between all Arab political/sectarian
factions. Not too long after his disappearance from Iraqi politics, the Iraqi
political and security situation took a U-turn and back to the level on which
security was once again out of control and sectarian fighting has been on the
rise.
However, to show its gratitude
for the genuine partnership the people of Kurdistan and their leadership have
offered to the US mission in Iraq, the US government has kept the name of these
two friendly Kurdish political parties, the KDP and PUK, in Tier III of the US
Immigration Law—the Tier that contains names of the organizations that have
been black-listed by the US government as terrorist organizations. The organizations that are listed
in Tier III, are groups that “engage in” or have subgroups that “engage in”
terrorist activities. But, in the case of the KDP and PUK it has never
been true—even after the chemical attacks on Halabja and the Anfal operations by
Saddam Hussein’s forces that destroyed most parts of Kurdistan, the people of
Kurdistan and their leadership have never engaged in terrorist activities.
Further, since the liberation of Iraq, these Kurdish political parties have
completely ceased using their armed forces.
Mr. President, looking at the US policy in general and the behavior of your
administration in particular with regard to the KDP and PUK, one could ask,
where in the world a democratic nation like the US could cooperate and partner
with “terrorist” organizations? How in the world a democratic government like
the US could rely on and closely work with not one but two “terrorist”
organizations to achieve its goals in a far away country like Iraq? Why in the
world, US presidents, including you Mr. President, invited these two “terrorist”
leaders to the White House and referred to each of them as “Mr. President?” If
they are indeed terrorists, how could it be possible for the top US officials
including the Vice President, Secretary of State, Secretary of Defense and
others to visit Hewlêr and Baghdad, and hold meetings with these two Kurdish leaders?
If they are indeed terrorists, how have these Kurdish leaders been greeted by
other world leaders and treated like “Statesmen?” Why does the US have its consulate
in Kurdistan—the region, which is administered by the KDP and PUK? These are legitimate
and ethical questions and we believe the US government should provide a
response to each of them.
Further, your own administration acknowledged to some extent the
cooperation of the KDP and PUK by offering an exemption under the Immigration
and Nationality Act (INA) Section 212(d)(3)(B)(i), which is for the granting of
visas to some KDP and PUK members (mainly their leadership), this would only
imply that America has softened its policy in order to pursue its own interests
and not to acknowledge the truth of the legitimacy of the KDP and PUK as
political parties and US partners in Iraq. Because, these political parties are
still officially kept in this tier that represents terrorist organizations; and
this behavior Mr. president, is hypocritical, at best.
The way in which the US government treats these two Kurdish political
parties is contradicting every democratic principle and the values for which
America stands; and it certainly is an insult to the national integrity of the
people of Kurdistan. These Kurdish political parties are loyal US friends and
reliable partners in the region, thus they should not be treated in such a
disrespectful manner as to be listed as terrorist organizations.
We believe that the US government should either find a way out of such a
wrong-headed policy and remove these Kurdish parties from the list of terrorist
organizations or if the US believes it needs to maintain its relations with
these Kurdish political parties, then your administration should come out and
give a convincing explanation to the American people as to how and why America
works with terrorist organizations. You know Mr. President, what the US does
vis-à-vis the KDP and PUK, is not good for the American image in the eyes of
the people of Kurdistan.
In conclusion, Mr. President, your administration knows that the KDP and
PUK are not terrorist organizations, but rather have a national agenda and struggled
to achieve national rights for their oppressed people. You know Mr. President
that the leaderships of the KDP and PUK have played a very important role in
stabilizing Iraq after Iraq was liberated—a role that “terrorist” organizations
could not play. Therefore, we ask of you to please remove these political
parties from the list of terrorist organizations.
We shall continue to pray for your success.
Sincerely yours,
Kirmanj Gundi
Kirmanj Gundi, Ed.D.
Professor
Tennessee State University
Dear Dr. Gundi
ReplyDeleteI am agree with your request litter to the president Obama about DDP & PUK issues as you know I am one of the North American immigration law victims.
but America and Canada are 100% correct at this kdp and puk issue also I am agree with the North American's law makers.I think with out any ddoubt and both two Kurdish parties are still an terror organisation which the principles of a terrorist organised groups mentioned in the article 34 -a of the law.
With kind regards,
Nia Amin
Dear Kak Nia,
DeleteThank you for your comment. I am aware and saddened by your situation. Perhaps, there are other decent Kurds like you, who have been punished by the same US policy. This was one of the several reasons that I wrote and sent the letter. Hope the Kurdish leadership will take the matter more seriously.
Regards,
Kirmanj G.
I agree with Mr. Kirmanj Gundi concern and share his believe in this regards. After years of conflict in the region specifically in Iraq, US government should recognize who is only true alliy of US in the Middle East and never change their position with US present in the region. Saying all that Kurdish parties need to have stronger unity among the all parties and position and stop being influenced by regimes in the area, especially Iran.
ReplyDeleteWhen those parties (PUK & KDP) fall into non- conditional- non- agreement situation to protect themselves under United States, they should think of consequences like this.
ReplyDeleteThis is not insulting to people of Kurdistan, but, to PUK & KDP. Please do not try to confuse people .
Best way to implement this idea is: to try through your political ties with Us and don't expect people to participate in such a game.
The 2 parties are directly responsible for this , not people.
Farman :
ReplyDeleteI do agree with you Dr Gundi because the idea is not defending both parties it is more than that .unfortunately the prevoius commentator did not understand the idea he /she write some thing with out having any forsee or understand the real reason of such letter, and let me be clear that I respect the previous comentator under the Anonymous name and he/she has the right to write any thing however we have to be reasonable when we giving our opinion about any subject in the world . and at the end let me encourge you Dr.Gundi and say go a head for this kind of movement ,because we still after many year and having many kurdish people living in the western country but no one want or beleive that the decesion of any leader or Government can be adjusted if we work with them or we inform them what we need.
Farman
Dear Kak Farman,
DeleteThank you for your feedback and understanding. Every one is fee to express his/her point of view, certainly on my blog!
Regards,
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI heard the same information some times ago and I had doubted the truth of it! Unfortunately, it seems to be true. Well, the US government should understand that the American troops wouldn't be able to enter Iraq in 2003 without Kurds' and Peshmargas' assistance. So, if the US gov. considers these two Kurdish political parties as terrorists, then why they cooperated with them? Is USA a terrorist partner?!!
ReplyDeleteDear Selar Xanim,
DeleteThank you for your comment. The US would like to continue with this policy. I think the Kurdistan leadership should take the matter to the US officials and ask them to remove them from the list of terrorist organizations.
Regards,
Do you have a liaison office in Washington, D.C.?
ReplyDeleteDear Unknown,
ReplyDeleteThank you for your question. No I have no liaison office in Washington D.C.
Regards,
سلاوو کاک کرمانج گوندی
ReplyDeleteکاتیکی زوره لهیک دابراووین !!!!!
ئایا خیونهوارمان کهمه له حوکومهتی کوردستان که جیگای قوباد پرر کاتهوه له واشنگتون
که ئهم مهسهله گرنگانه چاوو دیری بکات؟؟؟؟؟
براتان حمید سیادی
من تێناگەم کورد بۆ فێرنابێت لە مێژوو؟
ReplyDeleteئەمریکا کورد بە کەری بار دادەنێت و ناهەقی ناگرم. سەرکردەکانی کورد هەمیشە کوردیان کردۆتە ژێر باری باری ئەمریکا بێ بەرامبەر و بێ ڕێککەوتنی نووسراو. ئەمریکا خۆی بو خۆی تیرۆر و تیرۆریستان بەخێو دەکات و بەرەڵایان دەکاتە گیانی خەڵکی بۆ ئەوەی ببنە بیانوو بۆ دەست تێوەردانی ئەمریکا لە کاری وڵاتان بێ ئەوەی کەس گازندەی لێ بکات.
گلەیی لە میللەتی کورد دەکرێت کە نا سازوو لەبەر ئەوەی جاشەکان لەگەڵ سەدام بوون و چوون لە باوشی ئەمریکا خەوتن و لەبییریان چوو کە مسوڵمانن و ئەمریکا عەشکەنجەی مسوڵمانان دەکات لە سەر تا سەری جیهان.
ڕێزدار کاك ئاری
Deleteسوپاس بۆ تێبینییەکەت. بەو ئومێدەی کە سەرۆکایەتیی ئەو حیزبانە زێتر سەرنج بدەنە ڕووداەوکانی جیهانێ و هەول بدەن کە لە ئاستی بەرپرسیارێتیی نیشتیمانیی بەرنامەڕێژیی بکەن
شادکام بی
کرمانج